Criticize The Judgements Not Judges

Justice Pushpa Ganediwala

Justice Pushpa Ganediwala of Bombay High Court Nagpur Bench tendered her resignation after the Collegium of Supreme Court did not elevate her as permanent Judge. The judgement given by justice Pushpa Ganediwala on January 15, 2021 in the case Libnus Kujur Vs State of Maharashtra was seen as much controversial and subsequently overruled by the Supreme Court. Her interpretation in the case regarding sexual assault against a minor as skin to skin was criticised widely.

When the judgements are not good, it must be criticized and discussed. But is it okay to criticize a judge personally? "To error is the human being." We shouldn't judge the capability of a judge on his/her single judgement or dicision.

When decisions are handed down, some people say they are right and some say they are wrong. These are the people's opinions and they have the right to hold them. Everyone has their own opinion and perspective, and it must be respected. If any wrong judgement is handed down, it can be challaged in superior court or be reviewed. It will be more moral if we criticize the judgement and not the judge.

Comments

The Assassination of Peshawa Narayan Rao

Portrate of Peshawa Narayan Rao Murder of Narayanrao Peshwa was a particularly difficult episode in the reign of Maratha Empire, second only to the Panipat Third War. All the diplomats and powerful noblemen and ministers in Pune were perplexed at sheer cruelty and blatancy of the gruesome incidence. The assassination of Peshwa Narayan Rao took place on August 30, 1773 in Pune, Maharashtra. The 18 year old Peshwa of the Maratha Confederacy was murdered during the Ganesh Chaturthi Festival, which took place from August 21–31. The assassination was plotted by his uncle Raghunath Rao (Raghobadada ) and his wife Anandibai. Raghunath Rao wanted to remove his teenage nephew and become the Peshwa (Prime Minister). On the eve of Ganesh Chaturthi, assassins entered Shaniwarwada to assassinate Narayanrao. Despite his attempts to flee for his life, the merciless Gardi assassins mercilessly killed him, tearing him to shreds. His mutilated ...

List of Documents Required for JMFC EXAM

Candidates preparing for JMFC keep copies of the followings documents List of documents: Graduation and LL.B: Fresher Candidates- 1. Std. X mark sheet and passing certificate. 2. Std. XII mark sheet and passing certificate. 3. Graduation : last year mark sheet, passing certificate, degree certificate 4. LLB and B.SL. LL.B. : • Each SEMESTER mark sheet • Final year passing certificate • Third year passing certificate and final year passing certificate for 5 yr course students • Degree certificate • Sanad 5. Enrollment Id card 6. Domicile 7. Translation certificate given by College ( after prelims ) 8. LLM: • Each year mark sheet • Final year passing certificate • Degree certificate (if you have) 9. Caste certificate and Non - creamy layer certificate fo...

Death of A Lawyer

Adv Manoharrao Gomare Saheb Everyday thousands of people die around the world but we care only then when someone near to us is no more. People come and people go. It does not change our life. But some people change our life and the way of our thinking. The one such person i have seen in my life is Advocate Manoharrao Gomare Saheb. Adv Manoharrao Gomare Saheb died on 20th December 2023 by old age. Manoharrao Gomare Saheb was a civil advocate practicing in Latur District Court. I did not have a personal interaction or talk with him ever. But I have seen his life very closely. My introduction to him was of less than three years. I listened him for the first time at Latur District Bar liabrary during his autobiography book inauguration. A polite man with a poetic heart. Mother died after giving him birth. He couldn't see his mother's face also. In his many sad poems...

Vishnu Karle

Search This Blog